Short answer: choose Shopify if you want the largest app ecosystem, the highest-converting checkout and the easiest day-to-day management. Choose BigCommerce if you sell B2B, run a large or complex catalogue, or want to keep your own payment gateway without paying extra transaction fees. Both are fully hosted, both scale past eight figures, and both can be moved to the other in 8–14 weeks.
How do Shopify and BigCommerce differ in 2026?
| Shopify | BigCommerce | |
|---|---|---|
| Hosting | Fully managed SaaS | Fully managed SaaS |
| Checkout | Shop Pay, one of the best-converting checkouts available | Solid native checkout, customisable on higher plans |
| Third-party gateway fees | Extra fee unless you use Shopify Payments | No extra transaction fees on any plan |
| B2B | Native on Shopify Plus | Native B2B Edition, strong quote and price-list tools |
| Catalogue | Variant limits raised, but options still simpler | Handles large catalogues and many product options well |
| Apps | Largest ecosystem in ecommerce | Smaller, more curated ecosystem |
| Headless | Hydrogen and the Storefront API | Catalyst and a mature GraphQL API |
| Sales-based plan limits | No | Yes — plans step up as annual revenue grows |
Which is cheaper, Shopify or BigCommerce?
It depends on how you take payments and how fast you are growing. Shopify charges an extra fee when you use a gateway other than Shopify Payments, which can add up for stores with negotiated processor rates. BigCommerce charges no extra fee, but moves you to a higher plan once your trailing annual sales pass each plan's threshold. Model both against your real order volume and payment setup before deciding — the monthly plan price is rarely the number that matters.
When is Shopify the better choice?
- You are a direct-to-consumer brand and checkout conversion is the biggest lever.
- Your team wants to install an app rather than brief a developer.
- You plan to sell across social, marketplaces and retail POS from one admin.
- You expect to grow into Shopify Plus for automation, B2B and expansion stores.
When is BigCommerce the better choice?
- B2B is a core channel: customer groups, price lists, quotes and purchase orders.
- Your catalogue has thousands of SKUs with many options and custom fields.
- You already have a payment processor contract you want to keep.
- You prefer more built-in features and fewer paid apps.
Is it hard to migrate between Shopify and BigCommerce?
Not if it is planned. Products, customers, orders, collections and content all move with structured exports and migration tools. The parts that need real care are URL redirects (both platforms use different URL patterns), customer passwords (customers usually need to reset), app replacements, and theme rebuilds. See our step-by-step plans for BigCommerce to Shopify and Shopify to BigCommerce.
What about SEO on each platform?
Both are good enough to rank. Shopify forces some URL prefixes (/products/, /collections/) and BigCommerce gives slightly more URL control. In practice rankings come from content, speed, internal linking and structured data — not the platform. What loses traffic is a migration without a redirect map.
How do you decide in one afternoon?
Answer four questions:
- Is B2B more than 30% of revenue? Lean BigCommerce.
- Is checkout conversion your biggest growth lever? Lean Shopify.
- Do you need to keep your current payment processor? Lean BigCommerce.
- Does your team want apps over custom development? Lean Shopify.
For the full side-by-side table, see Shopify vs BigCommerce. If you want a second opinion on your own numbers, talk to DoodleWeb — we build and migrate stores on both.
Seattle agency · Seattle, WA
A full-service digital agency working in WordPress, Drupal, Shopify, Webflow, React, and React Native. We partner with universities, nonprofits, governments, and growing brands to ship sites that hold up after launch.
