Online donations to nonprofits grew again in 2025, and the majority of the growth went to organizations that treated their donation page like a product, not a form. If your donation rate has been flat for two years, the fix is almost never a bigger email push. It is a better page, a faster site, and a more honest funnel. Here is what actually moves the number in 2026.
Why are our online donations stuck?
The most common causes, in order of frequency: a slow site, a friction-heavy form, a donation page that reads like a legal disclaimer, no recurring-giving default, missing mobile wallet options, and a thank-you experience that treats the gift as the end of the relationship.
What is the single highest-impact change we can make?
Move recurring giving from a checkbox to the default. In every serious study since 2020, defaulting the "make this monthly" option (with a clear one-time toggle) increases monthly donor conversion two to four times without meaningfully reducing total donors. Monthly donors have five to seven times the lifetime value of one-time donors. This one change often outperforms every other optimization combined.
How should the donation form itself be built in 2026?
Six rules:
- One page, one goal. Do not stack membership, tribute, and general giving on the same form.
- Suggest smart amounts. Three to five preset amounts based on your average gift, plus an "other" field.
- Enable Apple Pay, Google Pay, and PayPal. Mobile wallets convert 20 to 40 percent better than card entry on mobile.
- Ask the minimum. Name, email, amount, payment. Address only when required by tax law or premium fulfillment.
- Show impact per amount. "$25 provides one week of after-school snacks" outperforms "$25" every time.
- Confirm inline. No jarring redirect to a third-party page.
Which donation platform should we use?
For most nonprofits under $10M in annual revenue: Givebutter, Donorbox, or Fundraise Up. All three are fast, conversion-optimized, and integrate cleanly with the CRMs nonprofits actually use. Above $10M: Classy, iDonate, or a custom implementation with a payment orchestration layer.
How does site speed affect donations?
Directly. A donation page that takes four seconds to load on mobile converts roughly half as well as one that loads in under two. We covered the fix in how to fix slow nonprofit websites. If your PageSpeed mobile score is under 70, no amount of form optimization will overcome the drag.
What about the thank-you page?
The thank-you page is the highest-attention moment a donor will spend with your organization all year. Do not waste it on a receipt. Show three specific things:
- The impact their exact gift will have, in plain language.
- A one-click share to social with a pre-written message.
- A soft ask to become a monthly donor (if they gave one-time) or increase (if they already give monthly).
Well-designed thank-you pages generate 5 to 15 percent additional revenue at zero acquisition cost.
How do we improve giving from email campaigns?
Match the campaign to a dedicated landing page, not the generic donation page. Preserve the amount, the story, and the ask from the email into the page. Every seam between the email and the donation form costs conversions.
What about crypto, DAFs, and stock gifts?
Add them only after the fundamentals are right, and add them where they belong: a "more ways to give" page, not the primary donation flow. Adding six payment options to the main form increases friction more than it adds donors.
Where to go next
Read the companion pieces on the nine reasons nonprofits struggle with online donations, the nonprofit donation website diagnostic, and the nonprofit website development guide for online giving. Or book a free donation-funnel audit.
Seattle, WA
A full-service digital agency working in WordPress, Drupal, Shopify, Webflow, React, and React Native. We partner with universities, governments, and growing brands to ship sites and products that hold up after launch.
